Want the wider picture?
Simple words that keep you connected and out of coaching mode.
See Parent Play StyleChild Does Commentary Instead of Playing Football: Give It a Slot
Parent Play Style
Your child narrating the match is still playing football, just a different part of it.
A child who does commentary instead of playing football is still playing: narrating, celebrating and announcing the score is imaginative play, and for many children it is how they join in. The trick is to give the commentary a proper slot inside the five minutes, so the broadcast, the celebration and the kicking each get their turn.
For a long time I treated the running commentary as a delay to the real game, and only noticed my own five minutes going quicker once I stopped fighting it. Below is a five-minute plan, three roles to rotate and a simple test for when to let it run.
It is real play
Why Your Child Narrates the Match Instead of Playing
Most children who commentate are doing what children have always done: taking a game and turning it into a story with a voice, a crowd and a replay. Commentary lets a child be the player, the pundit and the crowd at once, and imaginative football play like this needs no fixing.
There are a few common reasons. They may be copying the matches they see, and if the voice comes from the telly, a few short bursts of real matches are covered in watching football with your child. They may feel safer narrating than risking a miss. Or they may simply like the sound of the moment.
One honest caution. If the commentary seems to replace every kick because a miss feels scary, that is a confidence question rather than a commentary one. The quiet approach is the same: give the narrating a place and keep the kicking small. Commentary does not need switching off. It needs a border.
Read the moment
Child More Interested in Commentating Than Playing: Redirect or Let It Run?
Commentary is play. The only thing to protect is the five minutes.
Let it run when the ball is still moving even if the voice is loud, your child is smiling and the commentary is about the game in front of you. Also let it run when the score or the replay is part of what they want to do next.
Step in gently when the ball has not moved for a full minute, a celebration is being replayed for the fourth time, they are walking backwards watching an imaginary camera near a flowerbed or a step. Step in too if someone is starting to get fed up, whether that is you or a sibling.
Stepping in does not mean switching the commentary off. It means offering a slot. If you notice you are the one narrating every touch, stop coaching, start playing covers that mirror image.
Tonight's five-minute plan
A Pretend Football Commentary Game for Kids: The Commentary Slot
The Commentary Slot is a five-minute game that gives the broadcast, the kicking and the celebration a turn each. All you need is a wooden spoon, a ball, a small goal and a kitchen timer.
- 1
Broadcast (60 seconds). Your child takes the microphone and calls the match before it starts: who is playing, what the weather is like, what could go wrong. Nothing is kicked yet. A kitchen timer or a count of 60 does the clock.
- 2
Kick-off (about 3 minutes). Real play, with one ball, one small goal and any rules you already use. The commentator is now a player and may keep commenting, but the ball must move at least every few seconds.
- 3
The replay rule. A goal or a good touch earns one 10-second replay. Your child may celebrate, re-enact it or call it in slow motion once, then it is on to the next go. A second replay waits for the interview.
- 4
Post-match interview (about 1 minute). Swap over: you hold the spoon and ask three questions about a bold moment, the best touch and who they would thank. Your child answers like a broadcaster, and the five minutes ends on the commentary they wanted.
I once spent an entire evening as the pitchside reporter beside the flowerbed, holding a wooden spoon and being asked about a goal that never really happened. The actual kicking got squeezed into the last ninety seconds. Hence the timer. The times are a starting point, so move them to suit your child.
"Shall we do sixty seconds of commentary first, then kick-off?"
For a long replay: "Shall we save that one for the interview?"
To restart: "Shall we get the next goal in before the final whistle?"
Give the voice a job
Three Roles When the Commentary Will Not Stop
If the microphone will not go down, change who holds it. Swap every couple of goes so your child gets all three roles, and let them choose which comes first.
Commentator
The voice has the microphone and calls the play for two rounds, then hands it over.
Manager
Your child plans and shouts the next move from the touchline, which way to aim and which foot, and then plays it. Talk turns into a plan.
Player
The microphone goes to you, and your child plays while you do the commentary in your own over-the-top voice.
What is known, and what is not
What the Research Says About Pretend Play and Self-Talk
Children talk to themselves while they play, and that talk, called private speech, is common in the preschool years. In one study of 47 children aged about 3.7 to 5.5 in a US city, children used more pretend, role-based talk when a task was framed as play than when it was framed as a job to finish. Read the study on private speech and pretend play. The researcher set up the play, the children were preschoolers, and it was not about football or commentary.
A randomised trial of 67 children aged 5 to 6 found that pretend play improved how coherently children told stories, and that pretend play with an adult improved word and grammar use too. Read the trial on pretend play and storytelling. Some children dropped out between tests, nobody followed them up later, and it used fairy tales in kindergartens, not garden football.
A systematic review of 33 studies of children aged 3 to 7 found pretend play was the most promising of the play types for emotional wellbeing. Read the review of play and emotional wellbeing. Results were not followed up over time, and over half the studies were set in medical contexts.
The American Academy of Pediatrics tells parents to say yes when a child asks to play and to let children lead. Read the American Academy of Pediatrics' advice on play.
None of this studies commentary on a child's own football, and these studies do not show that a commentary slot will change your child. For what to say back once the microphone is yours, see what to say during play.
Quick answers
Common Questions About a Child Who Commentates
Is it normal for my child to do commentary instead of playing football?
Yes, for many children. Narrating and celebrating is imaginative play, and it is a common way to join in. It can become a problem when it swallows a short session, and a slot gives it a border. If it replaces every kick because a miss feels scary, that is a confidence question rather than a commentary one.
Should I stop my child commentating while we play?
Rarely. Give it a slot instead: sixty seconds before kick-off, a ten-second replay after a goal and a pretend interview at the end.
What is a pretend football commentary game for kids?
A short game where the child calls the match with a spoon microphone before and after real play, as in the Commentary Slot above.
How do I get my child to play, not just commentate?
Offer the roles in turn: commentator, manager, then player. Ask "Shall we do sixty seconds of commentary first, then kick-off?" and keep the ball moving.
Keep going
Where to Go From Here
Three places to go next, depending on what your child needs.
What do I say once the microphone is mine?
How much to say during play, and what helps.
See what to sayIs the voice copied from the telly?
Short windows of real matches that fit around play.
See watching football togetherTonight's five minutes
Hand over the spoon for sixty seconds, then kick off.
One wooden spoon, one kitchen timer, one ball and a replay rule. The commentary gets its slot and the kicking gets its minutes.